Electric Car Review

ELECTRIC CARS


SuperDriver has 2 Electric Cars

Are they any good?

Updated 1 November 2020


This review is from my perspective - Ian Radford, DVSA Approved Driving Instructor and manager of SuperDriver.  I will never go back to petrol or diesel!


I wanted to be different, i needed a change.  So i swapped my manual tuition car and went into automatic instruction and bought an electric car.  That was in 2015.  I'm now on my fourth and EVs are now a common site and many instructors now see the benefits.  But wow they are expensive... However, used cars are now becoming more affordable.


Environmental Credentials

Lets cut to the chase, are they more environmentally friendly than a petrol/diesel?  YES.  There are no fossil fuels burned by the car so no exhaust fumes.  My electricity supplier is green so my car is literally powered by the sun, sea and wind.  So running the car is environmentally friendly.  But what about manufacturing it?  There are bigger brains than mine writing about this so click here for an article from TopGear.

20200802_140916
1carfrontnew
1Leaffrontside

Maintenance

Maintenance is minimal as there are less moving parts.  In 6 years my cars have not required much maintenance.  There were no power train faults or battery faults.


What do they cost?

These cars are not cheap and that is changing... slowly.  Used prices are coming down.  50Kwh batteries are game changes giving 200 plus miles of range.  That's plenty for me as a driving instructor.  My Renault Zoe was £22k and that is with the battery included.  That was back in October 2021.  I've done over 40,000 miles.  There's been a few faults but nothing that has stopped me working.


Waiting times for new EVs can be long.  If you want one now, buy a pre-reg or a 1 year old car.     


All the main car manufacturers have new EVS.  Prices start from around £20k.  The lowest priced EV seems to be from MG with great specs and 50kw plus battery.

charger
My home charger
meter
My electric meter

What do they cost to run in electric, how do you calculate it for the tax man?

I have a meter that was fitted with my car charger unit at a subsidised rate.  I charge my car overnight.  My electricity supplier is British Gas and the tariff is called specific for Electric car owners.  The benefit is that between 12am and 5am my cost per kilowatt is 7.9p.  An App calculates how much energy i have used and the cost for my accounts.  I rarely do more than 110 miles in a day - so my electric cost per training day is around £2.50.  As at March 2025.

What are electric cars like to drive?  How far will it go?

It's the number one question i get asked.  Range depends on how efficient the car is and the size of the battery.  My Renault Zoe will do 230+ miles in the summer and in winter about 170 - that's mixed roads driving.  If i have a heavy right foot or if i am travelling at motorway speeds the range will decrease.  I can easily do 6 training hours per day and that is sufficient for my needs.


Electric cars are smooth and quiet.  A relaxing place to be.  You cannot tell that a gear change is happening like some petrol/diesels, because there are no gears.  Its just forward and reverse.  I've never driven a Rolls Royce but I would imagine the gear changes are equally smooth.  That's where the comparison ends though!  The Renault Zoe has a 'engine sound' at low speed (less than 18mph), this alerts pedestrians to it.  It's a false noise, the motor is ultra-quiet.  The air conditioning is louder than the car! 


Everything is within reach, its very simple to drive.  The touch screen is ok.  I'm not into meddling with it so its at all its basic settings.  It links okay to the app that allows me to start charging at the touch of a button if its plugged in.  I can also set the heating controls to cool the car or warm it up without setting foot outdoors.  It clears the windscreen and warms the car up perfectly on a cold winters day.


Cars with batteries are heavy, i would say half a ton more at least compared to their petrol/diesel equivalent in the super mini size category.  It doesn't feel like it but on the motorways the Zoe feels planted and less swayed in windy conditions.


There's plenty of reviews out there and lots on you tube.



CHARGING

There are several levels of charging available.


3 pin plug - takes ages to get any meaningful charge but can get you out of trouble.

7kw per hour  - at home and out and about.  Gives you about 30 miles of range per hour.

22kw 3 phase - if the conditions are right takes about 3.5 hours to fill Zoes boots

Rapid - if the conditions are right takes about 1.5 hours to fill.  Some cars charge up much faster.


Some charges out and about are free but i have no idea where they are.  I made certain i had all the apps to help me access my local charge points.  The charging infrastructure in Sheffield is poor but getting better.  When i purchased my first Electric Car i could get access to charge points really easily.  It is noticeably busier now and sometimes i have to wait... a long time.  Sometimes the parking bay is blocked by a diesel or petrol car. This is infuriating.  But not as infuriating as when a EV is plugged in and not charging.  ZapMap & PlugShare are great apps to find out where your nearest charging point is.

DSCF9390
DSCF9391

LONG JOURNEYS

I have 2 long distance trips to make every year.  Devon and Scotland.  Plan Plan and more Planning is needed.  Where are the chargers.

WAS IT THE RIGHT DECISION FOR ME?

Absolutely.  The Renault Zoe looks like any other car and really doesn't drive much different.  All the controls are where they should be and it isn't overly complicated.  It suits me and my customers love it.  Its cheaper to run and so far more reliable.  Over the coming years more and more driving instructors have and will move to electric especially in advance on the ban of new petrol and diesel car sales.


I am happy to talk more about my experience with Electric Cars, feel free to call on 07812377119.  BBC news have provided an interesting article including Q&A - click here.